Washington Supreme Court January 25, 2001, 69454-1 (Godfrey v. Hartford Cas. Ins. Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-01-2001
16 P.3d 617 (2001) 142 Wash.2d 885 John A. GODFREY and Gertrude M. Godfrey, husband and wife, Petitioners, v. HARTFORD CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, a foreign corporation, Respondent. No. 69454-1. Supreme Court of Washington, En Banc. Argued October 26, 2000. Decided January 25, 2001. *618 Carl Palmer, Seattle, for Petitioner. Lane, Powell, Spears, Lubersky, Charles C. Huber, Linda Blohm Clapham, Reed McClure, William Robert Hickman, Seattle, for Respondent. Bryan Patrick Harnetiaux, Harbaugh & Bloom, Gary Neil Bloom, Debra Leight Stephens, Spokane, Amicus Curiae on Behalf of Washington State Trial Lawyers Association Foundation. *619 TALMADGE, J.[*] John and Gertrude Godfrey obtained a $165,000 arbitration award against their insurer, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company (Hartford) from a three-member arbitration panel in an uninsured/underinsured motorist (UIM) claim. Pursuant to the Hartford policy, the arbitration panel decision on liability was final, but either party could seek a trial de novo in court on damages if dissatisfied with the panel's decision. Where the parties submit all issues of liability and damages to an arbitration panel, Washington's Arbitration Act (Act), chapter 7.04 RCW, our code of arbitration, makes the trial de novo provision in Hartford's policy unenforceable as against public policy. We reverse the decision of the Court of Appeals, restore the judgment of the trial court, and award the Godfreys their attorney fees on appeal pursuant to RAP 18.1. ISSUES 1. Is the provision for a trial de novo in the Godfreys' Hartford insurance policy unenforceable because it violates the public policy embodied in the Act? 2. If the provision for a trial de novo is unenforceable, would Hartford be deprived of its right to a trial by jury pursuant to Washington Constitution article I, section 21? 3. If the Godfreys prevail, are they entitled to attorney fees for vindicating the arbitrators' decision?
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit