Supreme Court of Colorado December 3, 2001, 00SC492 (Preston v. Dupont)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-2001

combined-opinion

35 P.3d 433 (2001) James M. PRESTON, D.D.S., Petitioner, v. Renee DUPONT, Respondent. No. 00SC492. Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc. November 13, 2001. As Modified on Denial of Rehearing December 3, 2001. *434 Davis Graham & Stubbs, LLP, Dale Harris, Andrew M. Low, Joel N. Varnell & Associates, J. Gregory Morrell, Denver, CO, Attorneys for Petitioner. Leventhal & Brown, PC, Anthony J. Viorst, Denver, CO, Attorneys for Respondent. Kennedy & Christopher, P.C., John R. Mann, Denver, CO, Amicus Curiae for Colorado Health and Hospital Association, Amicus Curiae for Physician Insurers Association of America. McDermott and Hansen, William J. Hansen, Denver, CO, Amicus Curiae for Colorado Trial Lawyers Association. Montgomery Little & McGrew, P.C., Robert N. Spencer, Patrick T. O'Rourke, Englewood, CO, Amicus Curiae for Colorado Medical Society. Justice MARTINEZ delivered the Opinion of the Court. In this case, we determine whether, in medical malpractice actions, which are governed by the Colorado Health Care Availability Act ("HCAA"), noneconomic losses or injuries caused by physical impairment or disfigurement are subject to the HCAA's $250,000 limitation on noneconomic damages. Resolution of this issue necessitates that we determine the relationship between section 13-21-102.5, 5 C.R.S. (2001), which limits noneconomic damages in general, civil actions, and section 13-64-302, 5 C.R.S. (2001), the section of the HCAA that limits noneconomic damages in medical malpractice actions. Additionally, we decide whether the jury in a medical malpractice action should be instructed to award a separate category of damages for physical impairment and disfigurement in addition to the statutory categories set forth in section 13-64-204, 5 C.R.S. (2001), of the HCAA. We affirm the court of appeals, although pursuant to different reasoning.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.