Wyoming Supreme Court December 5, 2001, 00-134 (Kroenlein v. Eddington)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-2001

GOLDEN, Justice.

[T1] This appeal requires that we consider various issues arising from passage of an annexation ordinance and the issuance of a liquor license. Appellee the Town Council of the Town of Torrington (Town Council) passed an annexation ordinance for property belonging to Appellees Eddington, Hill, Mar-latt (property owners), 77 Capital Corp. Before the annexation was effective, the property owners applied for a retail Hquor license. Appellants Robert L. Kroenlein and Betty Kroenlein (Kroenleins) sought a declaratory judgment that the annexation ordinance and liquor license were void because statutory requirements were not properly followed, and Appellee Eddington, Torrington's town attorney, had participated in the decision-making process despite a conflict of interest. The district court ruled that because the initial liquor license had expired by passage of time, any questions regarding issuance were moot. It further determined that the annexation ordinance was properly enacted pursuant to Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 15-1-407. Summary judgment was entered in favor of all appellees.

[¶2] Kroenleins' appeal requires that we determine whether the mootness doctrine precludes review of procedural defects in issuing a liquor license; whether a town attorney is prohibited from holding a liquor Hi-cense either by statute or conflict of interest; and whether the annexation ordinance is valid. We affirm.

*1210

ISSUES

[¶3] Kroenleins present this statement of the issues:

1. Are defects in the original issuance of a liquor license rendered moot by its renewal during the course of litigation?

a. Procedural defects which do not recur on renewal

b. Jurisdictional defects which remain at renewal

2. Is the annexation procedure provided in W.S. § 15-1-407 subject to the requirements of § 15-1-408(c) and (d) and the findings required by § 15-1-402(a) and other annexation statutes?

3. Is a prosecuting attorney a person prohibited from holding a liquor license under W.S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.