Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston) May 3, 2001, 01-00-00143-CV (Valero Marketing & Supply Co. v. Kalama International, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-05-2001

Opinion issued May 3, 2001

In The

VÉâÜà Éy TÑÑxtÄá

For The

Y|Üáà W|áàÜ|và Éy gxåtá

NO. 01-00-00143-CV

____________

VALERO MARKETING & SUPPLY COMPANY, Appellant

V.

KALAMA INTERNATIONAL, LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, Appellee

On Appeal from the 129th District Court

Harris County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. 97-49288

OPINION

This is an appeal from a summary judgment disposing of a breach of contract

complaint, rendered in favor of appellee, Kalama International, LLC. (“Kalama”).

Appellant, Valero Marketing and Supply Company (“Valero”), complains the trial

court erred in (1) granting Kalama’s summary judgment motion and denying Valero’s

summary judgment motion; (2) considering “usage of trade” evidence and ignoring

the existence of a fact issue on “usage of trade”; and (3) not finding Kalama was

required under the Uniform Commercial Code to notify Valero of the requirement that

a methanol dedicated or methanol clean barge was necessary to take delivery of

methanol. We affirm.

Background Facts

Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes warned, “In most contracts men take the risk

of events over which they have imperfect or no control.” Ferry v. Ramsey, 277 U.S.

88, 95, 48 S. Ct. 443, 444, (1928). The undisputed facts of this case illustrate this

admonition.

After negotiating a price, a third-party broker brought together Valero, a refiner

and marketer of petroleum products, and Kalama, a marketer of various chemicals.

Valero and Kalama subsequently entered into a contract, drafted by Valero, dated June

16, 1997, wherein Kalama agreed to sell Valero 20,000 barrels of methanol ASTM D

11552-891 at $.59 per gallon. The contract specified Valero would take delivery of

1

This type of methanol is 99.85% pure methanol.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.