Court of Appeals of Washington July 9, 2001, Nos. 45384-0-I; 45386-6-I; 45387-4-I; 45969-4-I (State v. Templeton)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-07-2001

Ellington, J.

CrRLJ 3.1 provides that the right to counsel accrues “as soon as feasible” after arrest. We are asked to decide whether the Supreme Court exceeded its powers in enacting the rule. We hold the court did not exceed its powers, the rule is valid, and the results of the breath tests in these cases were properly suppressed.

*144I

Four cases are consolidated in this discretionary review. Each Respondent was stopped by a State Patrol officer, arrested for driving under the influence (DUI), given Miranda1 warnings, and transported to the police department. Each was advised of the right to talk to an attorney before answering any questions, and to have an attorney present during questioning. Each waived those rights. Each Respondent was also given implied consent warnings,2 and each agreed to submit to a breath test. After answering additional questions, each took the breath test. Once the test results were in hand, each was cited for DUI.

In the cases against Templeton, Marsh, and Marginean, the district court suppressed the results of the breath test, holding the advisement of rights failed to satisfy CrRLJ 3.1. The Post court refused to suppress. On appeal, the superior court held that suppression was required in all four cases. We granted discretionary review, and affirm the superior court.

II

CrRLJ 3.13 provides that the right to counsel shall accrue “as soon as feasible after the defendant has been arrested,”4 and that an arresting officer is required to advise an arrested person of his or her right to a lawyer “as soon as *145practicable.”5 According to the State, the rule amounts to judicial creation of a substantive right, which exceeds the Supreme Court’s rule-making authority. According to Respondents, the rule is procedural and squarely within the Court’s province.

Neither the state constitution nor the federal constitution confers a right to counsel immediately upon arrest.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.