New York Court of Claims January 10, 2001, Claim No. 96736 (Barbosa v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-2001

OPINION OF THE COURT

Terry Jane Ruderman, J.

Claimant seeks damages for injuries she sustained while she was incarcerated at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility (Bedford) from June of 1996 until February 10, 1997, during which time she was raped by Correction Officer Thomas *927Haynes. The trial of this claim was bifurcated and this decision pertains solely to the issue of liability.

On January 16, 1998, Correction Officer Thomas Haynes pleaded guilty to the crime of rape in the third degree in acknowledgment that he had sexual intercourse with claimant on February 10, 1997 at Bedford. An inmate is deemed incapable of consent to a sexual act with an employee of the State Department of Correctional Services (Penal Law § 130.05 [3] [e]).

Claimant testified that in June 1996, while she was incarcerated at Bedford, she was raped for the first time by Haynes. She further testified that one month later she was raped again by Haynes. After the second incident, she advised Sergeant Cliff Richmond what had happened and, at his request, prepared a written statement for him. She also confided in Sergeant Richard Budd, Sergeant Steven Fredricks, and Correction Officer Bonnie Pawlak. Although claimant -received assurances that her concerns would be passed along, there was no change in Haynes’ presence around the facility.

Budd offered to place claimant in protective custody. Since this meant that claimant would be confined to her cell for 23 hours a day, claimant viewed the suggestion as a form of punishment and declined the offer. On February 10, 1997, claimant reiterated her fears of a future rape to Correction Officer Bonnie Pawlak. According to claimant, Pawlak said she would talk to “somebody” and took claimant to her work assignment.1 Later that evening, Haynes raped claimant for the third time. Claimant secured evidence of the crime and Haynes was arrested three days later.

The deposition testimonies of Budd, Richmond, Fredricks and Pawlak were admitted into evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.