New York Supreme Court March 6, 2001 (People v. Owens)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-03-2001
OPINION OF THE COURT
David D. Egan, J.
This is a death penalty case. Defendant John Owens is charged with two counts of murder in the first degree, three counts of murder in the second degree, and three counts of rape in the first degree. This court by its decision dated August 17, 2000 severed for trial one count alleging defendant raped victim “S.C.” (People v Owens, Sup Ct, Monroe County, Aug. 17, 2000, Egan, J., motion No. DEF-32.) The District Attorney *381filed a notice of intent to seek the death penalty pursuant to CPL 250.40 on January 24, 2000.
In this case defendant has not sought to enter a guilty plea, either before or after the District Attorney filed the notice of intent to seek the death penalty. Nonetheless, defendant challenges the constitutionality of the guilty plea provisions of CPL article 220, and CPL 250.40 and 400.27 as interpreted by the Court of Appeals in both Matter of Francois v Dolan (95 NY2d 33 [2000]) and Matter of Hynes v Tomei (92 NY2d 613 [1998]). (See NY Const, art I, §§ 1, 2, 5, 11; US Const, art I, § 10; 5th, 6th, 8th, 14th Amends.) Defendant asks this court to strike the notice of intent to seek the death penalty, allow him to enter a guilty plea, if he so elects, or offer argument at sentencing that the law prohibited him from entering a guilty plea in this case.
In Matter of Hynes v Tomei (92 NY2d 613 [1998], supra) the Court of Appeals found the 1995 death penalty statute had a so-called Jackson infirmity, stating:
“Capital defendants under the New York statute who are awaiting trial and are offered a plea are still faced with the choice Jackson declared unconstitutional: exercise Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights and risk death, or abandon those rights and avoid the possibility of death.” (Id., at 626, citing United States v Jackson, 390 US 570, 582 [1968].)
Instead of invalidating the entire death penalty statute, the Court excised the offending guilty plea provisions set forth in CPL 220.10 (5) (e) and 220.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit