Nassau County District Court July 23, 2001 (Young v. Woodcrest Club)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-2001
OPINION OF THE COURT
Michael S. Alongé, J.
This novel case involves the attempt by two former members of a golf club to recover a portion of the club’s initiation fee. The defendant has moved to dismiss under CPLR 3211 (a) (3), statute of limitations, and CPLR 3211 (a) (2), claiming this Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction.
*707Plaintiff Edward R. Young is asking for a judgment for $15,000 and $5,000, which he states is “a portion of funds paid by the plaintiff * * * referred to as a ‘bond’ ” which he alleges was refundable on resignation from the defendant’s club. Plaintiff Dr. Louis J. Weinstein is asking for a judgment for $15,000 in partial return of his initiation fee and $2,500 as part of the “bond.”
This motion to dismiss was brought by the defendant on the grounds that the District Court does not have subject matter jurisdiction over the action since the amounts asked for exceed the jurisdictional limits, or in the alternative, that the applicable statute of limitations has expired. Of these two contentions, the more serious is the statute of limitations problem under CPLR 213 (2), which provides that the statute of limitations for a breach of contract is six years.
Mr. Young, an attorney, was a member of the club’s Board of Governors and chaired its legal committee. He became a member of the Woodcrest Club on or about June 1, 1989. Defendant Weinstein became a member of the club on or about June 1, 1990. Mr. Young evidently paid $25,000 as an initiation fee, while Dr. Weinstein paid $15,000. Both plaintiffs claim that at the time of joining, and as a condition precedent, they were promised that should the initiation fee be reduced within two years of their initial membership they would receive a credit. The amount of the credit is unclear from the moving papers and from the pleadings.
Both plaintiffs resigned their memberships on October 1, 1995 and demanded a refund of their balance in reimbursement of the moneys owed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit