Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County May 22, 2001, no. 0308 (Knipmeyer v. Bell Atlantic Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-2001

SHEPPARD JR., /.,

This is a class action against Bell Atlantic Corporation and its local operating companies. The plaintiffs, Kevin and Joanne Knipmeyer, claim that the phone companies misrepresented the meaning of the term “nonpublished telephone number.” At issue are the defendants’ preliminary objections. Because the “filed rate doctrine” bars the Knipmeyers’ claims, the court sustains the objections and dismisses the complaint.

FACTS

The defendants — collectively, “Bell Atlantic” — are Bell Atlantic Corporation and its nine local operating companies: Bell Atlantic-Delaware, Bell Atlantic-Maryland, Bell Atlantic-New Jersey, Bell Atlantic-Pennsylvania, Bell Atlantic-Virginia, Bell Atlantic-Washington, D.C., Bell Atlantic-West Virginia, New York Telephone Co. and New England Telephone & Telegraph Co.1 The local operating companies serve 10 states and the District of Columbia. The Knipmeyers are Pennsylvania *227residents and customers of Bell Atlantic-Pennsylvania. They paid Bell Atlantic-Pennsylvania a premium for a nonpublished telephone number. A nonpublished telephone number is a number that is not listed in the telephone directory or in Bell Atlantic’s directory assistance service.

Bell Atlantic has a website through which a customer from any of the 10 states or the District of Columbia can order phone service from the local operating company serving the pertinent area. Among the pages on the website is a page for each state with the title “directory assistance.” On this page the customer selects one of three options for his directory listing: (1) “listed in phone book;” (2) “not listed in phone book, but listed in directory assistance;” or (3) “nonpublished: not listed anywhere.” Complaint, exhibit B.

Another page for each state has the title “nonpublished telephone number.” This page further describes nonlisted and nonpublished telephone number services:2

“Nonlisted telephone number — Want a little privacy?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.