Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 11, 2001 (Brunelle v. Lynn Public Schools)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-01-2001
Ireland, J.
The plaintiffs, the Brunelles and Pustells, are parents who oversee the home education of their school-aged children. After prevailing in Brunelle v. Lynn Pub. Schs., 428 Mass. 512 (1998) (Brunelle I), where we declared that the plaintiffs’ right to educate their children at home could not be conditioned on evaluative home visits by school officials, the plaintiffs filed a motion for attorney’s fees. A judge in the *180Superior Court denied their motion, and they appealed. We granted the plaintiffs’ application for direct appellate review. Because we conclude that the plaintiffs are not entitled to attorney’s fees, we affirm, the Superior Court judge’s order.
1. Facts and procedural history. The underlying facts giving rise to this claim are set forth in Brunelle I. We summarize them here. The plaintiffs notified Lynn school officials of their intention to educate their children at home. As part of their examination of the submitted home education proposals, the school committee, acting on behalf of the school department, required the parents to allow “the Superintendent (or designee, i.e., the Principal) to periodically . . . observe and evaluate the instructional process and to verify that the Home Instruction Plan is being implemented as authorized by the Committee.” Brunelle I, supra at 513. The plaintiffs refused to submit to these observations and evaluations in their homes. Consequently, the school committee disapproved both the Pustells’ and the Brunelles’ home education plans2 and, shortly thereafter, initiated a criminal complaint against the Brunelles in the Lynn Division of the District Court Department, pursuant to G. L. c. 76, §§ 2 (failure to cause child to attend school) and 4 (inducing absence of minors). A similar complaint was not filed against the Pustells, whose 1994-1995 home instruction plan was approved by the school committee in order to permit the Pustells to home school their children until the litigation was resolved.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit