United States Court of Federal Claims February 14, 2001, No. 95-153C (Alaska Pulp Corp. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-02-2001
OPINION
BASKIR, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff, Alaska Pulp Corporation (“APC”), alleges that the United States Forest Service in various ways breached its timber contract. Among other things, APC claims that the government’s implementation of the Tongass Timber Reform Act, Pub.L. No. 101-626, 104 Stat. 4426 (1990) (“TTRA”), repudiated and materially breached the contract with APC. The matter before us is APC’s motion for partial summary judgment regarding the government’s liability on the TTRA claim.
While admitting that the TTRA breached the contract, defendant contends that APC has failed to establish that it was materially harmed by the statutory provisions. Furthermore, defendant asserts that even if the government repudiated the contract, it may not be held hable because the TTRA was not the operative cause of APC’s economic problems, and because APC waived its repudiation claim.
We reject each of defendant’s arguments and GRANT plaintiffs motion for partial summary judgment as to liability.
BACKGROUND
We have dealt extensively with some of the facts of this case in adjudging other cross-motions for summary judgment. Previously the issues involved the proper interpretation of the contractual obligations of the parties, specifically whether APC was required to operate a pulp mill for the entire period of the contract. We held that it was not. Alaska Pulp Corporation v. United States, No. 95-153C (Fed.Cl., May 25, 2000)(unpub.) We repeat many of those same, undisputed facts below.
The Contract
In October 1957 the United States Forest Service and a Japanese company then known as the Alaska Lumber & Pulp Co., Inc. (subsequently renamed Alaska Pulp Corporation), entered into Timber Sale Contract No. 12-11-010-1545 (“Contract”), a 50-year contract for the sale of timber in the Tongass National Forest in the then-territory of Alaska. The United States Forest Service permitted APC to cut timber and purchase the logs, and APC agreed to do so subject to certain conditions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit