United States Court of Federal Claims February 21, 2001, No. 00-610 C (SDS International v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-02-2001
OPINION AND ORDER
HEWITT, Judge.
This is a post-award bid protest action brought by an unsuccessful offeror against the United States. Plaintiff, SDS International (plaintiff or SDS), protests the decision of defendant, Department of the Air Force (defendant or Air Force), to award a contract to CBD Training, Inc. (intervenor or CBD) for contract aircrew training (CAT) and courseware development (CWD) for F-117 airplanes. CBD is an intervenor in this proceeding. The matter is before the court on plaintiffs request that the court enjoin the performance of the contract by any offeror other than plaintiff. Plaintiff has moved for summary judgment. Defendant and interve-nor have cross-moved for judgment on the administrative record and summary judgment, respectively.
Plaintiff argues that defendant’s evaluations of plaintiffs and intervenor’s technical proposals were inconsistent; that defendant’s evaluations of plaintiffs and intervenor’s past performance were unreasonable; that defendant improperly relied on an undisclosed manning estimate in evaluating plaintiffs and intervenor’s technical proposals; and that defendant’s price analysis was flawed. Defendant and intervenor contend that defendant’s evaluations of plaintiffs and intervenor’s past performance and technical proposals were reasonable; that there were no rigid internal estimates guiding the procurement; and that defendant’s price analysis was reasonable as well.
Plaintiff has also moved for leave to supplement the administrative record. The court addresses that motion in section II below.
For the following reasons, the court denies the protest.
I. Background
On April 10, 2000, defendant issued Solicitation and Request for Proposal No. F44650-00-R0006 (RFP). Administrative Record (AR) at 1237. The RFP sought proposals for CAT and CWD in connection with the training of pilots for F-117 airplanes. Defendant’s Statement of Facts (DSF) H l.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit