United States Court of Federal Claims September 7, 2001, No. 92-872C (American Savings Bank, F.A. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-09-2001
ORDER
SMITH, Senior Judge.
The court has under consideration defendant’s motions to compel liability discovery and plaintiffs’ motion for entry of judgment as to liability.
The genesis of this controversy is defendant’s motion for a continuance to conduct fact discovery prior to responding to plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment. Plaintiffs apparently refused to provide additional liability discovery on the ground that their summary judgment motion had presented a Wmsiar-type capital forbearance contract virtually identical to those recognized by the Supreme Court. Defendant, in its RCFC 56(g) motion, and in its subsequent motions to compel liability discovery, argued that liability discovery was needed before it could respond to the motion. Plaintiffs’ motions for entry of judgment pursuant to RCFC 58 were subsequently filed on the ground that defendant had failed in its obligation to respond to their summary judgment motion. Meanwhile the parties, while arguing over the need for any remaining liability discovery, nonetheless completed expert discovery.
First, the court agrees with plaintiffs that they have submitted to the court one of the strongest prima facie demonstrations of the existence of a Wmsiar-type contract. In fact, based on plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, it can certainly be argued that plaintiffs have made a stronger prima facie case than was made in the original Winstar test eases: there is an Assistance Agreement which expressly incorporates the two fore-bearanees at issue into the contract. Moreover, there even exists a second promise that would appear to satisfy defendant’s own original unmistakability argument advanced in the three original Winstar cases: the letter signed by FHLBB and FSLIC General Counsel Jordan Luke (the Luke Letter) warranting that the transaction agreement “constitute[s] valid and binding agreements” and is “enforceable against the Receiver and the Corporation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit