Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit January 16, 2001, No. 98-16555 (Carmen v. San Francisco Unified School District)

KLEINFELD, Circuit Judge:

This case turns on summary judgment procedure. The issue is whether a judge must consider materials outside the motion papers and things referred to therein.

Facts

Plaintiff Gwendolyn Carmen holds state certification to teach elementary school. For many years, she worked as a day to day substitute teacher in San Francisco.