Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit July 5, 2001, No. 98-56447 (Seal 1 v. Seal A)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-07-2001
WILLIAM A. FLETCHER, Circuit Judge:
Appellant Abraham Gale (“Gale”) worked for ten weeks for Packard-Bell NEC, Inc. (“PBNEC”). After being fired by PBNEC, Gale filed a qui tam action against that company under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), 31 U.S.C. §§ 3729-3733, alleging that it had committed fraud by selling computers to the government as new even though they contained used parts. The government declined to intervene in Gale’s FCA suit, but nonetheless initiated criminal and civil investigations into PBNEC’s allegedly fraudulent practices. The United States Attorney allowed Gale to review documents obtained during at least one of those investigations, as well as during its investigation into one of PBNEC’s then-competitors, Appellee Zenith Data Systems, Inc. (“Zenith”). After learning from the government documents he saw in the office of the United States Attorney, as well as from oral disclosures by government attorneys in that office, that Zenith was probably involved in the same type of fraud as PBNEC, Gale filed a separate FCA action against Zenith. The government, PBNEC, and Zenith subsequently reached a proposed settlement to which Gale objected. After an evidentiary *1157hearing, the district court held that it did not have jurisdiction over Gale’s FCA action against Zenith and dismissed the complaint. Gale appeals that dismissal.
We agree with the district court that it lacked jurisdiction over Gale’s Zenith action, and we affirm.
I
Gale was employed for ten weeks by PBNEC as Manager of the Computer Department. He was fired during his probationary period, in December 1994. Three months later, Gale wrote a letter to the government alleging that PBNEC had committed fraud against the government. PBNEC sold to the government computers that it claimed were new and for which it charged new-computer prices. Gale alleged that in fact those computers contained used parts. Gale mentioned only PBNEC in his letter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit