Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit September 11, 2001, 699 (No. 99-3473)

265 F.3d 699 (8th Cir. 2001) JOHN HOYLE, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF ARKANSAS TAXPAYERS' RIGHTS ASS'N, AND AS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE CLASS OF MORE THAN 100,000 ARKANSANS WHO PETITIONED FOR PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 4 OF 1998 AND FURTHER AS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE CLASS OF ALL REGISTERED VOTERS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; JOE HOYLE; EARL OXFORD; TOM TINSLEY, APPELLANTS, v.