Supreme Court of Vermont December 19, 2001, No. 01-282 (Demgard v. Demgard)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-2001

Plaintiff appeals the Rutland Superior Court’s dismissal of his claim for contribution from defendant, plaintiffs ex-wife, for payments plaintiff made on a promissory note the parties executed prior to their divorce. Plaintiff asserts that his superior court action is not a collateral attack on the parties’ final divorce order and the superior court’s determination to the contrary was erroneous. We agree and reverse and remand.

On April 12, 1996, the parties, who were married at the time, executed an unsecured promissory note in which they promised to repay a sum of $20,000, with interest, to Henry J. and Frances C. *527Bargmann over a period of forty-eight months. In April 1998, defendant filed for divorce in Rutland Family Court. The family court issued its final judgment and decree on February 9, 2000 after a contested hearing. The divorce judgment included a division of the parties’ property, granting defendant title to the marital residence and the roughly eight acres of land upon which the residence sits. Although that property was formerly owned by plaintiffs mother, the court awarded defendant title to the property “free and clear of any debt or other interest” of plaintiff. The order did not contain a specific provision relating to the parties’ individual or marital debts, including the promissory note to the Bargmanns.

In March 2001, plaintiff filed the present action seeking contribution from defendant for payments plaintiff allegedly made on the promissory note. Defendant moved to dismiss the suit on the grounds that plaintiff was attempting to relitigate the property distribution encompassed in the divorce judgment. The superior court agreed and dismissed the action. Plaintiff appealed.

Plaintiff contends that the superior court misunderstood the nature of his claim by concluding that he was attempting to collaterally attack the property division in the final divorce judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.