Supreme Court of South Carolina May 14, 2001, No. 25290 (Edge v. State Farm Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-2001

TOAL, Chief Justice:

We agreed to answer the following question certified by the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina:

Must a person, who claims her insurer assessed unauthorized surcharge points, exhaust the administrative remedies available under S.C. Reg. 69-13.1(IV) and S.C.Code Ann. § 38-3-210 before filing a civil action?

FACTS

In 1996, plaintiff Patricia Edge was involved in a two car accident with Ann Shull. Both drivers were insured by defendant State Farm Insurance Company. A ticket was issued to Shull at the scene of the accident for disregarding a traffic signal.

After an internal investigation of the accident, State Farm decided Edge was predominantly at fault for the collision. State Farm paid damages to Shull from Edge’s policy. State Farm assigned two surcharge points1 to Edge pursuant to 25A S.C.Code Ann. Reg. 69-13.1(III)(H)(4) (Supp.2000), because it had paid Shull from Edge’s policy.

In October 1996, Shull either pled guilty to or forfeited bond on the charge of disregarding a traffic signal.2 Approximately *138one year later, despite Shull’s plea or forfeit, State Farm notified Edge it intended to increase her premium by more than $600. State Farm advised Edge it raised her premium because its investigation found Edge to be at fault for the accident.

Instead of paying the higher premium, Edge applied for insurance with Horace Mann Insurance Company. Although she was initially quoted a lower premium than State Farm’s quote, Horace Mann later notified her that State Farm reported her accident to the Comprehensive Underwriting Exchange, thus she would be assessed two surcharge points and her premiums would be substantially higher. Edge paid the increased premium for the Horace Mann policy. Horace Mann later removed the surcharge and lowered the premium rate after Edge provided documentation that Shull had been convicted of a moving violation in connection with the accident. Edge renewed her policy at the lower rate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.