Indiana Supreme Court April 18, 2001, 49S02-0104-CR-213 (Pennycuff v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-04-2001

combined-opinion

ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE

Jodi Kathryn Stein Karen M. Freeman-Wilson

Marion County Public Defender Attorney General of Indiana

Agency

Indianapolis, Indiana

Timothy W. Beam

Deputy Attorney General

Indianapolis, Indiana

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF INDIANA

TERRY PENNYCUFF, )

)

Appellant (Defendant Below), ) 49S02-0104-CR-213

) in the Supreme Court

v. )

) 49A02-9902-CR-117

STATE OF INDIANA, ) in the Court of Appeals

)

Appellee (Plaintiff Below). )

APPEAL FROM THE MARION SUPERIOR COURT

The Honorable Tanya Walton Pratt, Judge

Cause No. 49G01-9606-CF-088754

April 18, 2001

SHEPARD, Chief Justice.

A jury found appellant Terry Pennycuff guilty on two counts of

incest, three counts of child molesting, and one count of sexual misconduct

with a minor for carrying on a sexual relationship with his teenage

daughter over a three-year period. The Court of Appeals ordered a new

trial, holding that Pennycuff’s lawyer was ineffective for failing to

object to evidence that violated Pennycuff’s rights under Doyle v. Ohio.[1]

Pennycuff v. State, 727 N.E.2d 723 (Ind. Ct. App. 2000).

We conclude that the caselaw points to a different outcome.

How Pennycuff’s Trial Unfolded

The State’s first witness at trial was Pennycuff’s daughter, T.P.

(R. at 225.) T.P. described in detail numerous sexual advances by, and

contacts with, her father. (R. at 227-38, 244-54, 257-58.) Among other

things, T.P. accused her father of videotaping and photographing her in the

nude on two separate occasions. (R. at 233-34, 246.) She testified that

her father gave her money after some of their sexual encounters. (R. at

228, 234, 244.) She also said that some of these incidents occurred at

home while her brother was in another room, (R. at 245), although no one

besides herself actually witnessed any of the occurrences.

T.P. testified that Pennycuff had written words and initials on

certain pages of a calendar to memorialize some of these incidents. (R. at

250-51, 253-54.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.