Richmond County Circuit Court April 11, 2001, Case No. LE-2163-4 (Wimmer v. Green)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-2001
By Judge Melvin R. Hughes
This matter is before the court on the defendant’s Motion to Set Aside Juty Verdict On December 19,2000, a jury rendered a verdict for the plaintiff and against the defendant in the amount of $250,000. In his motion, the defendant asks that judgment be entered for the defendant or the verdict to be set aside as excessive or for remittitur.
The case arises out of a claim by plaintiff that defendant, an off duty City of Richmond deputy sheriff, assaulted her at a restaurant bar where defendant was providing private security. The evidence was in conflict over how an altercation leading to the plaintiffs becoming badly battered and bruised started. Plaintiff testified she was asked or taken outside and set upon by the defendant. Defendant testified that plaintiff initiated by striking him first. In the initial stage of the altercation, the evidence is essentially a one-on-one affair between plaintiff and defendant Others who witnessed fee fracas or fee aftermath came to fee parties later, after fee conflict had been initiated.
The defendant first contends that fee plaintiff is barred from recovering by fee “illegality” defense. Virginia does recognize this defense which precludes a party who voluntarily participated in an illegal act from recovering damages from other participants for injuries incurred as a result of fee illegal act See Johnson v. Campbell, 258 Va. 453 (1999). The defendant submits feat fee evidence at trial showed feat fee plaintiff hit the defendant first and therefore voluntarily participated in the assault.
*179The defendant is correct that some testimony at trial indicated that the plaintiff hit the defendant first. There was also evidence, however, that the defendant struck die plaintiff first The juiy, as trier of fact, obviously believed the testimony indicating that the plaintiff did not strike the first blow.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit