District Court, D. Massachusetts August 13, 2001, No. C.A. 96-10421-MLW (Markarian v. Connecticut Mutual Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-08-2001
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
WOLF, District Judge.
I. SUMMARY
Plaintiff Mark Markarian (“Markarian”) brought this putative class action on behalf of individuals who purchased certain types of life insurance policies from Connecticut Mutual Life Insurance Company (“Connecticut Mutual”)1 between January 1, 1980 and December 31, 1992. Markarian alleges that Connecticut Mutual intentionally engaged in *61deceptive sales practices by having agents use a “vanishing premium” sales strategy to sell life insurance policies.
The type of policy at issue in this case has been known both as the “Modified Paid-Up Option” and the “Modified Payment Option,” the abbreviation for both of which is “MPO.” In a 1981 communication to agents, Connecticut Mutual explained that:
MPO is a permanent insurance illustration that features an alternative way in which a policy may be paid-up through the use of dividend accumulations or dividend additions.
MPO differs from the traditional reduced paid-up method of using dividends to pay up a policy in that the paid-up date occurs so much earlier, and there is no sharp reduction in the death benefit when the policy becomes “paid-up.” The MPO approach is to have dividends accumulate at interest!,] or purchase paid-up additions for a sufficient number of years!,] such that annual dividends from then on plus either withdrawals from accumulated dividends or partial surrenders of paid-up additions will, based on the current dividend scale, be sufficient to pay all future premiums.
Connecticut Mutual’s board of directors determines its dividend level on an annual basis.
Markarian met with an insurance agent in May, 1987 to discuss different types of life insurance products. The agent made a sales presentation to Markarian that included an Illustration of a Connecticut Mutual MPO policy, which showed the amount and timing of premium payments, the dividends paid during the initial years of the policy, as well as other aspects of the policy.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit