District Court, N.D. Illinois September 17, 2001, No. 99 C 3586 (Zurba v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-2001
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
KENNELLY, District Judge.
In this case under the Federal Tort Claims Act, the Court found the defendant liable in a bifurcated trial and set a date for trial on the issue of damages. Defendant has moved in limine to preclude one of plaintiffs treating doctors, Dr. Cesar Romero, from offering what defendant has characterized as “expert” testimony.
*591Dr. Romero treated plaintiff in connection with her injuries that are at issue in this ease. Plaintiff disclosed Dr. Romero in response to interrogatories asking her to identify physicians who had treated her. Pltfs Response, Ex. 1. Defendant obtained copies of all of the records of Dr. Romero’s treatment of plaintiff. Plaintiff did not provide an expert report from Dr. Romero pursuant to Rule 26(a)(2). However, on December 22, 2000, plaintiffs attorney sent defendant’s attorney a letter stating that Dr. Romero, though not retained as an expert, would offer opinion testimony at trial based on his treatment of plaintiff and his education, training, and experience concerning the nature of plaintiffs condition, its cause, the permanency of her condition, and the necessity and cost of future medical care. Pltfs Response, Ex. 3.
Defendant took Dr. Romero’s deposition in late January 2001. Prior to the deposition, defendant’s counsel advised plaintiffs counsel as follows:
[I]n the event that the plaintiff seeks to offer expert opinions that fall within Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2), that Rule sets forth specific requirements regarding disclosure of the expert and a report. We expect that the plaintiff will comply with that Rule.
As matters stand, we understand Drs. Romero, Torrence and Franklin to be the plaintiffs treating physicians. Thus, we will proceed with the depositions of these doctors based on the understanding that they are plaintiffs treating physicians and not Rule 26(a)(2) experts.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit