District Court, S.D. Indiana December 3, 2001, No. IP01-0572-C-Y/F (Hartford Fire Insurance v. Guide Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-2001

ENTRY

FOSTER, United States Magistrate Judge.

On Request for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order (doc. no. 83) and Stipulated Protective Order (doc. no. 82).

For the following reasons, the Court declines to approve the parties’ stipulated protective order at this time.

First, the Court suggests that the parties reconsider the proposed order’s terms for disclosing “Special Confidential” material under U 4. Special Confidential material is defined as Guide’s privileged attorney-client communications and work product, H 2(b), yet disclosure of this material is permitted to the parties, their employees and attorneys, and to many third parties, including adverse third parties. Such disclosures would likely effect a waiver of the privileges. As noted below, while the parties might bind themselves by agreeing to limit waivers of privileges and protections, their agreement cannot bind third parties.

Second, the parties cannot, by H15, determine the grounds on which non-parties may challenge the parties’ designations under the protective order. Non-parties may challenge the propriety of the protective order and the parties’ specific designations thereunder according to the established legal standards and burdens at the time irrespective of the parties’ agreements. This is especially so when the question is the sealing of the official court record on briefing and at trial as provided in 11114(d), 9, and 10. In particular, that the parties will “suffer cognizable harm by broader disclosure” of information is not a legitimate ground alone for the Court to order the sealing of discovery materials or the court record.

Third, the parties are advised that 113(f) may have a more limited scope than they intend. While the parties might be able to bind themselves by agreeing to limit waivers resulting from inadvertent (or deliberate) disclosures, Cardiac Pacemakers, Inc. v. St. Jude Medical, Inc., No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.