District Court, D. New Hampshire May 29, 2002, CV-02-244-M (Senators v. Gardner, et al.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-2002

Senators v. Gardner, et a l . CV-02-244-M 05/29/02

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

Senators Clifton Below;

Burt Cohen; Lou D'Allesandro;

George Disnard; Mark Fernald;

Beverly Hollinqworth;

Sylvia Larsen; Caroline McCarlev;

Daniel O'Neil; Debora Piqnatelli;

and Katherine Wheeler,

Plaintiffs

v. Civil No. 02-244-M

Opinion No. 2002 DNH 106

William M. Gardner, Secretary of State;

Senator Arthur P. Klemm, Jr., in his

Capacity as N.H. Senate President; and

The New Hampshire Senate,

Defendants

O R D E R

Two of three named defendants have removed this legislative

redistricting case from the New Hampshire Supreme Court to the

United States District Court for the District of New Hampshire.

See 28 U.S.C. §§ 1441 and 1443(2). Given the time-sensitive

nature of the issues presented and the compelling interest of the

State of New Hampshire in reapportioning its legislative

districts, the court has given this matter expedited

consideration.

Removal is improper for several reasons, and the case is

hereby remanded to the New Hampshire Supreme Court.

First, all defendants have not consented to removal, as is

required. See, e.g.. Hill v. Phillips, Barratt, Kaiser Enq'q,

Ltd., 586 F. Supp. 944, 945 (D. Me. 1984) ("Where there are

multiple defendants, all must consent to or join in the petition

for removal.") (citations omitted). Here, Secretary of State

Gardner has neither consented to nor joined in the removal

petition.

Second, although the underlying state court petition makes

passing reference to federal statutory and constitutional

provisions, it is plain that the petition seeks relief based

exclusively upon state constitutional and statutory authority.1

1 For example, plaintiffs in the underlying petition

assert that, "The legislature's failure and refusal to form

constitutionally valid senate districts prior to the close of the

2002 regular session should be declared a violation of Part 2,

Article 26 of the N.H. Constitution." Petition at 10.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.