Supreme Court of Minnesota April 18, 2002, C0-01-1597 (Johnson v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-04-2002

OPINION

PAUL H. ANDERSON, Justice.

Randy Pool was kidnapped and murdered in McLeod County in July 1999. Following the murder, petitioner Toby Earl Johnson was arrested and indicted for first-degree intentional murder while committing a kidnapping, second-degree intentional murder, and kidnapping. Pursuant to a plea agreement, the state amended the first count of the indictment to aiding and abetting a premeditated intentional murder. Johnson then pleaded guilty to both the amended first count and to the second count of second-degree intentional murder. According to the plea agreement, if Johnson provided “useful” information to the state, he would be sentenced on the second count, but if he failed to provide such information, he would be sentenced on the amended first count. Ultimately, the district court accepted the plea agreement, convicted Johnson on the amended first count, and sentenced him to a mandatory life sentence. Johnson petitioned for postconviction relief, arguing that the plea agreement violated separation of powers because the agreement provided that the state had the “sole discretion” to determine (a) whether Johnson would be convicted of the amended first count or the second count, and (b) the actual length of imprisonment. The post-conviction court denied Johnson’s petition. We affirm.

The facts giving rise to Johnson’s conviction are as follows.

1

On July 14, 1999, Jason Caldwell and Salem Bernhardt were arrested at Randy Pool’s house on outstanding warrants. Berhnardt had been living with Pool and sold methamphet

*914

amine from Pool’s house. Caldwell came from out of state to visit Bernhardt.

Four days after the arrests, Heather Ecklund visited Bernhardt in jail. Bernhardt asked Ecklund to find out who had turned him and Caldwell in to the police. That evening, Ecklund and Tanya Caldwell went to Pool’s house and questioned Pool about Bernhardt’s and Jason Caldwell’s arrests and about some missing money and drugs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.