Court of Appeals of Washington October 8, 2002, No. 20690-4-III (Portch v. Sommerville)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-2002

Schultheis, J.

— Jason and Tami Portch appeal the trial court’s denial of their motion for a new trial. The motion was based on their contention that the trial court denied them the opportunity to exercise any of their peremptory challenges during jury selection. We agree they were denied the opportunity to exercise their peremptory challenges but find their refusal of the court’s offer to declare a mistrial renders the error harmless. The court’s denial of a new trial is affirmed, and the Portches’ request for attorney fees is denied.

Facts

The Portches sued Heather Sommerville for negligence arising from a motor vehicle accident. The matter was set for a jury trial in Spokane County Superior Court. The jury voir dire was not transcribed for the record, but it is not necessary for our analysis. The verbatim report of proceedings commences “during peremptory challenges of jury panel after it had been sworn and examined on voir dire by both counsel.” Report of Proceedings (RP) at 2.

*809The record reveals that Ms. Sommerville’s counsel properly exercised the defense’s three peremptory challenges, replacing jurors 2, 5, and 6 with jurors 13, 14, and 15 respectively. Counsel for the Portches “waived” as to the first 12 jurors, then jurors 13 and 14 and, later, juror 16 (as the alternate). Clerk’s Papers (CP) at 5. However, when the Portches’ counsel attempted to exercise a peremptory challenge on juror 15, the challenge was denied. The Portches argued they had not exercised any of their peremptory challenges and, as such, they were entitled to exercise their first peremptory challenge to excuse juror 15. Their counsel explained to the court, “I’m contending a failure to exercise a challenge to existing jurors who are in the box does not constitute a waiver of all challenges to the rest of the jurors who are not in the box.” RP at 3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.