Missouri Court of Appeals July 3, 2002, No. 24713 (State v. Warren)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-07-2002
JAMES K. PREWITT, Judge.
Pursuant to a stop on May 26, 2001 by the Missouri State Water Patrol on the Lake of the Ozarks in Camden County, Daniel M. Warren (“Defendant”) was charged with the class B misdemeanor of operating a vessel while intoxicated, in violation of § 306.111, RSMo 2000. Defendant filed a motion to suppress the State’s evidence of his intoxication, contending that the stop was illegal and a violation of his Fourth Amendment rights. Following a hearing on the motion to suppress, in which the issue was limited to whether the initial stop was legal and based on reasonable suspicion that Defendant had violated the law, the trial court granted Defendant’s motion. The State files this interlocutory appeal, pursuant to § 547.200.1(3), RSMo 2000.
In its one point relied on, the State asserts that the trial court erred in sustaining Defendant’s motion to suppress evidence because Defendant’s use and display of docking lights was a violation of § 306.100, RSMo 2000, since the lights were other than the navigation lights allowed by the statute while a vessel is under way. Therefore, according to the State, the Missouri Water Patrol Officer had reasonable suspicion to stop Defendant, making the initial stop legal and not in violation of Defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights.
At the evidentiary hearing on Defendant’s motion, Corporal Nicholas Humphrey (“Humphrey”) of the Missouri State Water Patrol testified that he initially stopped Defendant’s vessel because it was being operated with its docking lights displayed, which Humphrey believed to be a violation of § 306.100.2. Based on his training, Humphrey testified that the alleged violation is termed “displaying lights other than prescribed.” Under § 306.100.2, a vessel under way from sunset to sunrise is to exhibit navigation lights including a white light aft, green light starboard, and red light port. “[D]uring such time no other lights which may be mistaken for those prescribed shall be exhibited.” § 306.100.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit