Supreme Court of Colorado May 28, 2002, No. 00SC690 (Close v. People)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-05-2002

Justice MARTINEZ

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case presents the issue of whether a criminal defendant who is sentenced pursuant to the erime of violence statute, section 16-11-309(1)(a), 6 C.R.S. (2001), is entitled, upon request, to a proportionality review of his sentence, and, if so, what is the proper scope of such proportionality review. The trial court declined to conduct a proportionality review of defendant Close's sixty-year sentence. The court of appeals affirmed. People v. Close, 22 P.3d 983, 989 (Colo.Ct. App.2000). Both courts based their conclusion on the fact that the sixty-year sentence was the mandatory minimum sentence under the statute, reasoning that courts are not authorized to conduct proportionality reviews of legislatively mandated penalties, particularly when the penalty imposed is the minimum under the statute. We disagree with the reasoning, but affirm on different grounds.

We conclude that the current law governing proportionality review does include a well-established principle of proportionality through the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution and that Close was entitled to an abbreviated proportionality review of his sentence. We find that neither the statutorily mandated nature of the crime of violence statute nor the fact that the sentence imposed in this case was the minimum under that statute precludes a sentencing court from conducting an abbreviated proportionality review. More specifically, we hold that, because of the risk of a disproportionate sentence under the crime of violence statute, a defendant sentenced under that statute is entitled, upon request, to an abbreviated proportionality review, regardless of whether he was sentenced to the minimum possible sentence under that statute.

However, although we hold that the denial of a proportionality review was erroneous, we affirm the sixty-year sentence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.