Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Alleghany County May 15, 2002, no. GD 00-9001 (Advanced Telephone Systems Inc. v. Com-Net Professional Mobile Radio LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2002

FRIEDMAN, J.,

INTRODUCTION

This case arose from a contract between plaintiff, Advanced Telephone Systems Inc., t/d/b/a ATS Mobile Communications and defendant Com-Net Professional Mobile Radio LLC. In addition to recovering damages from Com-Net PMR LLC for an alleged breach of the contract, ATS also sought to recover damages from the other defendants by piercing the corporate veil.

At argument on motions in limine, it became evident that common facts gave rise to both an action at law (plaintiff vs. Com-Net PMR LLC) in assumpsit and an action in equity (plaintiff vs. all other defendants) for piercing the corporate veil. Therefore, only one evidentiary proceeding had to be conducted. This was followed by bifurcated decisions, a jury verdict for the action at law, and the instant adjudication for the action in equity. The trial was held before the undersigned commencing April 1,2002. At the conclusion of the evidence, the court directed a verdict on the issue of liability against defendant Com-Net PMR LLC, only, and the case was submitted to the jury on the issue of damages. On April 5, 2002, the jury returned a verdict in favor of ATS and *289against Com-Net PMR LLC in the amount of “$2.5 million plus attorney’s fees [in an uncontested amount of $102,000].’1

The jury’s role in the case was thereby concluded and we then proceeded, in equity, to consideration of whether to pierce the corporate veil and impose liability on the other defendants. Extensive oral argument was heard by the undersigned on April 16,2002, after both parties had submitted proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. For the reasons set forth below, we conclude that we cannot pierce the corporate veil and cannot impose liability for the breach by Com-Net PMR LLC on any of the remaining defendants.

ISSUES INVOLVED

ATS seeks to pierce the corporate veil of Com-Net PMR LLC so as to recover the jury award against it from the other defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.