Massachusetts Appeals Court April 18, 2002, No. 99-P-2128 (Private Lending & Purchasing, Inc. v. First American Title Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-04-2002

Grasso, J.

We consider in this appeal whether a title insurance policy that excepts a prior mortgage from its coverage must specify that the excepted mortgage contains a “dragnet” clause.1 More generally, the question posed is whether, more than merely referencing an excepted lien or encumbrance, the “Schedule B Exceptions” to a policy of title insurance must *533also state with particularity aspects of the identified lien or encumbrance that may affect the amount secured by the mortgage. We hold that, absent an undertaking to do more than issue a policy of title insurance, a title insurer need not do more than properly identify an excepted lien or encumbrance in the Schedule B exceptions to coverage.

The issue arises in the following context. Private Lending & Purchasing, Inc. (Private Lending), appeals from the entry of summary judgment dismissing claims for breach of contract, negligent misrepresentation, negligence, and violations of G. L. c. 93A and c. 176D against First American Title Insurance Company (First American) concerning two title insurance policies.2

1. Background.

A. The Triad loans. In 1990, Triad Finance Corporation (Triad) loaned $275,000 to Jose and Annemarie Pereira. The promissory note to Triad was secured by five parcels of real property owned by the Pereiras. As part of the loan, Triad insisted upon a mortgagee’s title insurance policy insuring the five parcels. Triad directed its attorney, R. David Cohen, to see to the documentation. In addition to his legal practice, Attorney Cohen was also authorized to issue title insurance policies as agent for First American.

Cohen conducted the requisite title examinations and discovered that the properties were encumbered by prior mortgages to Luso American Credit Union (Lusa) and others. Cohen admittedly did not read the Luso mortgages, each of which contained a dragnet clause.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.