Court of Appeals of Oregon July 31, 2002, 96-1155; A110810 (State v. Ventris)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-07-2002

HASELTON, P. J.

This case is before us for the second time, following our reversal of defendant’s two convictions for aggravated murder in State v. Ventris, 164 Or App 220, 991 P2d 54 (1999) ('Ventris I). In Ventris I, we also affirmed defendant’s related “convictions” for murder and robbery. Id. at 222. On remand, the state elected not to retry the aggravated murder charges. On resentencing, the trial court, over the state’s objections, merged defendant’s convictions for murder and robbery. The state now appeals, arguing that the court erred in merging the murder and robbery convictions and in failing to impose separate sentences for those crimes. As amplified below, we conclude that, given our disposition in Ventris I, the trial court’s characterization of defendant’s murder conviction as being one for felony murder, not intentional murder, was erroneous and exceeded the proper scope of our remand. Consequently, we reverse the trial court’s merger of defendant’s murder and robbery convictions and remand for further proceedings.

Defendant, for his part, cross-appeals, challenging the trial court’s adherence, in convicting defendant of murder, to another aspect of our holding in Ventris I. We affirm on the cross-appeal without further discussion.1

Because it is central to our treatment of this appeal, we recount at some length the posture and disposition of Ventris I. This case arises from the murder of Vergil Crist in Scappoose during the early morning hours of August 10, *1021996. Crist’s apartment had been burglarized, and the autopsy showed that he had been beaten on the head and chest with a rod and stabbed 13 times. Ventris I, 164 Or App at 223. Crist died as a result of the stab wounds. Id. Circumstantial evidence suggested that defendant had been involved in the crime, and, ultimately, investigating officers recovered a pair of defendant’s pants that bore traces of Crist’s blood. Id. at 224-25.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.