Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit September 25, 2002, No. 98-30112; D.C. No. CR-94-00289-01-HA (United States v. Beydler)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-09-2002

MEMORANDUM *

Terry Beydler appeals the district court’s denial of his motion to dismiss based on the Speedy Trial Act1 (STA) and the district court’s inclusion of a jury instruction to which he objected. We affirm.

I. Denial of Motion to Dismiss

Beydler argues that the district court erred2 in finding an “ends of justice” *476excludable delay without an adequate inquiry on the record. We reject Beydler’s argument because we find that the district court’s inquiry into the reasons supporting the delay was sufficient.

The district court’s inquiry touched on the two STA factors applicable to this case:3 (1) whether failure to find excludable delay would make continuing the proceeding impossible or result in a miscarriage of justice;4 and (2) “[wjhether the failure to grant such a continuance ... would unreasonably deny the defendant or the Government continuity of counsel, or would deny counsel for the defendant or the attorney for the Government the reasonable time necessary for effective preparation, taking into account the exercise of due diligence.”5 The two reasons the district court relied upon satisfy the STA “ends of justice” requirements: the reasons directly implicate the appropriate statutory factor, and the district court adequately inquired regarding these reasons on the record.6

Beydler’s contention that the district court failed to make an adequate inquiry lacks merit. First, the district court questioned the prosecutor about why the prosecutor could not use previous testimony from witnesses, but was persuaded that this would not be a complete solution because one critical witness had not testified at the first trial. Second, Beydler bears some responsibility because he initially requested a delay.7 Third, the district court made a general inquiry into the possibility of substituting prosecutors.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.