New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division December 30, 2002 (Jaquez v. National Continental Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-2002

The opinion of the court was delivered by

COBURN, J.A.D.

This case concerns coverage under the omnibus clause of an automobile liability insurance policy issued by defendant State Farm Insurance Company (“State Farm”) to defendant Erica Rochester. Plaintiff, Jacqueline Jaquez, a passenger in a car insured by defendant National Continental Insurance Company (“National”), was injured when that car was struck by Rochester’s car. Defendant Carlos Ribot was driving the Rochester car. State Farm denied coverage on the ground that Ribot did not have permission to operate Rochester’s car despite his receipt of its key from Rochester for the purpose of entering it and retrieving a pack of cigarettes. National settled plaintiffs uninsured motorists claim and sought indemnification from State Farm.2 On cross-*262motions for summary judgment, the trial court ruled in favor of State Farm, finding that coverage was not provided under the initial permission rule because Ribot had not been given permission to drive the Rochester car. We reverse.

On March 17, 1999, Rochester drove with her boyfriend, Carlos Alvarez, to the house of his sister, Mildred, in Newark. She parked and locked her car on the street in front of Mildred’s house. On entering the house, they found Mildred and Carlos Ribot, who was Mildred’s son and Carlos’s nephew. Rochester had known Ribot for about two years. After a while, Ribot asked Rochester for a cigarette. She said they were in her car, and she handed him the key, telling him he could get them. A few minutes after Ribot left, Mildred screamed, “Erica where is your car?” Rochester ran outside, saw that the car was missing, and immediately called 911 to report what she believed was a theft. Shortly thereafter, Rochester saw her ear coming down the street on a flatbed tow truck. Ribot had driven Rochester’s car a short distance and had been involved in the two-car accident which injured Jacqueline Jaquez.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.