Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit November 8, 2002, 02-3581 (Fidelity National Title Insurance Company of New York v. Intercounty National Title Insurance Company, Appeal Of: Myron M. Cherry & Associates LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-2002

EASTERBROOK, Circuit Judge.

Fidelity National Title Insurance contends that $20 million vanished from real estate escrow accounts under the control of defendants and related entities. It seeks a judgment for that amount in this diversity litigation. Five of the defendants — Intercounty National Title Insurance Co., Intercounty Title Co., INTIC Holding Co., Terry Cornell, and Susan Pe-loza (collectively the intic parties) — retained Myron M. Cherry & Associates LLC to represent them in the suit. The three corporations are defunct but have made claims against co-defendants (and third parties) that may have value; the financial status of Cornell and Peloza, who controlled the three corporations, is unclear. The intiC parties promised to pay Cherry an hourly fee for its services and to reimburse expenses. For some time they kept this promise. But about a year ago they began to fall behind, and by July 2002, when Cherry first moved to withdraw, they owed more than $430,000 in fees and out-of-pocket expenses. (The total now exceeds $470,000.) Cherry informed the district court that its clients had stopped paying and were making no efforts to engage new counsel. The district judge denied this motion to withdraw and a later one, making it clear that in her view Cherry' must represent the intic parties to the bitter end, no matter how much this costs (and no matter how little the in-tic parties pay), unless a new lawyer files an appearance on their behalf. Substitution is unlikely, because the district court’s order provides Cherry’s clients with free legal assistance, while the intic parties would have to give any replacement a hefty retainer (for Cherry anticipates that the trial of the suit may require lawyers’ time plus outlays for copying, transcripts, and other expenses that will bring the total tab to $1 million). Cherry, which does not fancy throwing good time after bad, asks us to reverse the district court’s order and to permit its withdrawal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.