Massachusetts Superior Court February 11, 2002, No. CA9804354 (Archer ex rel. Maureen G. v. Dare Family Services, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-02-2002
Hely, J.
A. Introduction
This case raises the important issue of whether the Commonwealth can be vicariously liable under the Tort Claims Act, G.L.c. 258, for alleged negligence by a foster parent who was caring for a foster child under an independent contractor arrangement with the Commonwealth. The court concludes that the Commonwealth can be vicariously liable in such an independent contractor situation, but vicarious liability is limited to cases where the plaintiff can prove that the particular foster parent was subject to direction and control by the Commonwealth.
On a related issue, the court concludes that foster parents are entitled to individual immunity and legal representation as “public employees” under G.L.c. 258, §2, regardless of the direction and control test.
With respect to the plaintiffs separate allegation of negligence by the Commonwealth in selecting the appropriate foster care placement for the child, the Commonwealth is entitled to discretionary function immunity under G.L.c. 258, § 10(b). On another separate claim, the City of Malden’s summary judgment motion must be allowed because the recreational use statute requires evidence of willful, wanton or reckless conduct. There is no such evidence in this case.
B. Basic Facts
The complaint alleges that Maureen G., a child in foster care, was injured when she rode a bicycle into an abandoned car. The abandoned car was in a public school parking lot in Malden. The accident was on September 3, 1995. This action was brought on behalf of the child by her guardian.
Dottie White was the child’s foster caregiver at the time. The Commonwealth’s Department of Social Services had custody of the child. DSS arranged for specialized foster care for the child through DARE Family Services, Inc. under the “Mentor DSS” program. DARE is a private independent contractor that arranges and provides for foster care for children needing a higher level of care under a contract with the Commonwealth.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit