Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division January 11, 2002 (Gallant v. Indian Ranch, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-2002

LoConto, RJ.

Aggrieved by the trial judge’s allowance of the defendant’s motion for summary judgment the plaintiff commenced this appeal in accordance with Rule 8A of the District/Municipal Courts Rules for Appellate Division Appeal. A summary of the undisputed facts as stated in the Expedited Appeal are as follows.

On May 25,1998, the plaintiff was attending a Memorial Day celebration at the Indian Ranch facility. As she was returning from a concession stand to the picnic area, she tripped over one of the many exposed tree roots that were in the area, causing her to fall forward and resulting in serious physical injuries.

Indian Ranch is an establishment offering services to the public and it includes camp ground facilities, as well as an amphitheater and picnic area There are many pine trees scattered throughout the property. The tree root over which the plaintiff tripped was covered by bark, was 4” tall and approximately 6” wide. It extended more than 3’ from the base of the tree. Several other exposed roots extended out from this particular tree and many more similarly exposed roots extended out from other trees in the area

*13At the time she fell, the plaintiff was walking back from the concession stand to the area where she and her friends had been enjoying the Memorial Day Jamboree. There were many other patrons in die area. There was no defined path from the picnic area to the concession stand. The route to and from the concession stand was through the area which was marked by the many exposed tree roots.

The plaintiff contends, and has so testified at her deposition, that on her return from the concession stand, she was carrying beverages on a tray and she was paying particular attention to avoid the many patrons who were walking around the area. A young tot was riding piggyback on the plaintiff at the time of her fall.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.