Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division August 13, 2002 (Craft v. Scofield)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-08-2002
Coven, J.
This is an action to recover unpaid attorney’s fees. A jury verdict was entered for the plaintiff attorney. The defendant has filed this Dist/Mun. Cts. R A D. A, Rule 8C, appeal on allegations of error in the trial judge’s exclusion of evidence and failure to issue curative jury instructions sufficient to remedy prejudicial statements by plaintiff’s counsel in his closing argument
On September 15,1994, defendant Stephen L. Scofield (“Scofield”) retained plaintiff Theodore L. Craft (“Craft”) as his attorney in connection with an Internal Revenue Service matter. When the initial retainer fee paid by Scofield was exhausted before any IRS settlement was reached, Craft proposed a fee schedule adjustment in a letter to Scofield dated January 18,1995. Scofield rejected both the proposed fee schedule and the eventual IRS settlement offer. On February 6,1995, Scofield notified Craft in writing that he was dissatisfied with the legal services provided by Craft and was discharging him. Following the discharge, Scofield retained counsel from a law firm in Georgia to represent him in the IRS matter.
Craft claimed at trial that during a telephone call on February 16,1995, he and Scofield made an oral agreement to extend the terms of their contract beyond the February 6,1995 discharge date. On March 6,1995, Craft sent a letter to Scofield (the “March 6 letter”) with an attached bill in the amount of $5,312.00 for legal services rendered by Attorney Craft The bill covered the period from January 18, 1995 through March 6,1995, and included both an outstanding balance owed by Scofield for legal work completed before February 6th and an additional $1,050.00 for legal services performed between February 6 and March 6, 1995. Upon Scofield’s refusal to pay the $5,312.00 in attorney’s fees, this action ensued.
Over Scofield’s objection at trial, the March 6 letter from Craft was excluded from evidence.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit