Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division September 24, 2002 (Patti v. National Amusements, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-09-2002

Coven, J.

This is an action in negligence to recover for personal injuries sustained in the collapse of a seat in the defendants movie theater. Judgment was entered for the plaintiffs. The defendantfiled this Dist/Mun. Cts. R A D. A, Rule 8C, appeal challenging the sufficiency of the evidence on the issue of liability and the propriety of the courts evidentiary rulings.

On May 29,1996, plaintiff Dr. Richard A Patti (“Patti”) suffered personal injuries when his seat collapsed during a movie presentation at the Showcase Cinemas of defendant National Amusement, Inc. (“National”) in Lawrence, Massachusetts. Patti and his wife, plaintiff Josephine Patti, went to National’s place of business to attend an afternoon movie and chose two seats on the left side of the theater, approximately eight to fourteen rows from the back. About thirty minutes into the film, Patti shifted his weight to change positions. His entire seat, base and unattached seat back, suddenly collapsed. In an attempt to break his fall, Patti grabbed the back of the seat in front of him and was able to reach a standing position without touching the ground. In the process of pulling himself up, Patti put considerable stress on his back and arms. He has experienced pain and restricted movement ever since despite undergoing years of treatment for his injuries. His medical bills exceeded $6,000.00. Mrs. Patti claimed a loss of consortium and a diminished quality of life due to her husband’s injuries caused by National’s Mure to inspect and maintain its theater properly in a safe condition for invitees.

After a trial without a jury, the judge found for the plaintiffs in the amount of $50,000.00,2 concluding that the National’s negligence caused Dr. Patti’s permanent, debilitating injuries and adversely affected Mrs. Patti’s quality of life.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.