Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit July 2, 2002, 01-1268, 01-1269 (Transclean Corporation, James P. Viken, Jon A. Lang, and Donald E. Johnson v. Bridgewood Services, Inc., Defendant/cross-Appellant)

CLEVENGER, Circuit Judge,

dissenting in part.

I agree with the majority’s resolution of the validity, damages, and attorney fees issues as well as its determination that the district court did not abuse its discretion in precluding Bridgewood from asserting noninfringement of claims 1-4 and 12 as a sanction for various discovery abuses.