West Virginia Supreme Court February 27, 2003, 30632 (McCoy v. Miller)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-2003

PER CURIAM:

William and Beverly McCoy appeal from two orders entered by the Circuit Court of Kanawha County on June 25, 2001, dismissing a second medical malpractice action they filed against Appellee Doctors Jay Requarth and John Chapman

1

on grounds of both

res judicata

and statute of limitations and against Dr. Scott Miller solely on statute of limitations grounds. The McCoys also appeal from a January 30, 2002, order refusing to reinstate their legal malpractice action against Steven Miller.

2

In

McCoy v. CAMC, Inc., (McCoy I),

210 W.Va. 324, 557 S.E.2d 378 (2001), this Court affirmed both the lower court’s dismissal of the McCoys’ first medical malpractice cause of action on grounds of failure to prosecute

3

and the trial court’s

*163

decision not to reinstate the action. Upon our full review of the orders at issue against the record in this case, we find no error and accordingly, affirm.

I. Factual and Procedural Background

Mr. McCoy underwent double coronary bypass surgery at Charleston Area Medial Center, Inc. (“CAMC”) on January 3, 1995. Although the surgery performed by Dr. Req-uarth, and assisted by Dr. Chapman, was performed without incident, Mr. McCoy’s sternum became separated during the recovery period and he alleged that he sustained a staph infection as a result of the surgery required to repair his separated sternum. Based on these alleged acts and the resulting injuries sustained, the McCoys filed their initial medical malpractice complaint against CAMC, Dr. Requarth, and Dr. Chapman on January 3, 1997. In them complaint, the McCoys alleged negligence, failure to warn, and loss of consortium.

The first civil action filed by the McCoys was dismissed by order of Judge Irene Berger on December 20, 2000, for failure to prosecute. In

McCoy 1,

this Court upheld both the dismissal order and the subsequent order of Judge Berger denying the McCoys’ motion to reinstate their cause of action and to amend them complaint.

See

210 W.Va. at 331, 557 S.E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.