Supreme Court of Iowa November 25, 2003, 01-1380 (Baker v. BOARD OF ADJ., CITY OF JOHNSTON)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-11-2003

LAVORATO, Chief Justice.

The petitioners filed a writ of certiorari against the City of Johnston Board of Adjustment (Board) in the district court challenging the Board’s grant of a variance regarding property owned by respondents Dallas E. Patterson and Connie A. Patterson. The Pattersons sought the variance before submitting to the Johnston City Council a plat covering the property in question.

Later, the petitioners joined several other individuals and the City of Johnston as respondents. Pursuant to a writ issued by the clerk of the district court, the Board filed a return on the writ.

See

Iowa R. Civ. P. 1.1404; Iowa Code § 414.17 (1997). Following a number of pretrial rulings, the district court agreed with the petitioners and ruled, among other things, that the Board could not grant the variance.

The respondents appealed raising a number of issues. One of those issues is whether the Pattersons were required to obtain the variance before submitting the plat for approval to the city council. We conclude they were not. For that reason, the case should have ended at the pretrial stage on the respondents’ first motion to adjudicate law points. Accordingly, we reverse the judgment of the district court and vacate all the rulings beyond the respondents’ first motion to adjudicate law points. We remand the case with directions.

I. Background Facts and Proceedings.

The Pattersons owned a 2.985 acre residential lot in an R-l (single family residential) zoning district in the City of Johnston, Iowa. A private drive created by a fifty-foot wide ingress/egress and utility easement provides access to the property. Thomas and Kristine Flynn granted the easement to the Pattersons, Robert and Barbara Britson, Kirby and Sharon Wil-more, and Ronald and Phyllis Onnen in 1988. At the time, the Britsons, Wilmores, and Onnens owned property adjoining the Pattersons’ property. The Wilmores sold their property to Lee and Kathy Baker in 1995.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.