Court of Appeals of Texas August 21, 2003, 2-02-387-CV (Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. Hamil)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-08-2003

OPINION

JOHN CAYCE, Chief Justice.

This is a trespass case. In four issues on appeal, Southwestern Bell Telephone Company (“SBC”) contends that there is insufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict and that the Hamils are not entitled to recover attorney’s fees. SBC also complains that the trial court abused its discretion by admitting evidence of compromises and offers to compromise by both parties. On cross-appeal, the Hamils argue that the trial court erred in setting aside the jury’s finding of malice sua sponte. We reverse and remand the case for a new trial.

Barry, Carolyn, and Dorothy Hamil (“the Hamils”) own two tracts of land in Mansfield, Texas. The two tracts were once part of a single, larger tract, but were split due to a taking by the Texas Department of Transportation for use as Texas Highway 360. The remaining tracts of land are an eleven acre tract on the east side of Highway 360 and a fifty-nine acre tract on the west side of the highway. Before Highway 360 came through, the land was bordered on the south by a street called Broad Street. When Highway 360 was constructed, Broad Street was rerouted. As rerouted, Broad Street runs parallel to the Hamils’ property boundary and then curves off to the south.

In October 1998, the Hamils discovered that SBC had buried a telephone line along the portion of Broad Street that ran parallel to their property. Instead of following Broad Street as it curved south, however, the phone cable continued in a straight line across the Hamils’ property. After confirming that there were no utility easements or rights-of-way on the property, Barry Hamil attempted to contact SBC, but was unsuccessful. As a result, he sought the advice of a real estate attorney. "When Hamil’s attorney confronted SBC regarding the problem, SBC repeatedly contended that the phone lines were within the Texas Department of Transportation’s right-of-way.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.