District Court of Appeal of Florida September 10, 2003, 4D02-3366 (Amato v. Intindola)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-09-2003
854 So.2d 812 (2003) Sal AMATO and Clara Amato, his wife, Appellants, v. Randolph J. INTINDOLA and City of Hallandale, Appellees. No. 4D02-3366. District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District. September 10, 2003. Rehearing Denied October 10, 2003. *813 Paul J. Kneski, Miami, for appellants. Mark Goldstein, City Attorney, Hallandale Beach, for appellees. WARNER, J. In this personal injury action, the trial court dismissed appellant's complaint after concluding that he perpetrated a fraud on the court. The trial court's dismissal was based on a videotape taken by an investigator which depicted appellant performing several activities that he testified at his deposition that he was unable to perform. We adopt the analysis of Jacob v. Henderson, 840 So.2d 1167 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003), and reverse, holding that dismissal with prejudice as a sanction was an abuse of discretion. Appellant, Sal Amato ("Amato"), age 76, was involved in an automobile accident with the city manager of Hallandale. Amato sued the City and its manager for negligence and alleged permanent bodily injury. Because of his claim, the City employed a private investigator who surveilled appellant and recorded his activity on two days approximately six months apart. On the tape of the first day, appellant is seen working on his truck, crawling partially underneath the vehicle, and changing a tire. On the tape of the second day, shot six months later, Amato is seen working around his home and climbing a ladder to the roof. While standing on the roof, he lifts some sort of electric motor to the roof with a rope and proceeds to clean out his gutters. At his deposition, taken two days after the second videotape was made, Amato testified that, as a result of the accident, he suffered a recurrence of back problems from an earlier spinal surgery as well as problems with his knee which prevented him from twisting and required him to walk carefully.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit