Court of Appeals of Maryland April 10, 2003, 90, Sept. Term, 2002 (Podgurski v. OneBeacon Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-2003

Opinion by

CATHELL, J.

This case arises out of a complaint for declaratory judgment, together with a motion for summary judgment, filed by Deborah Podgurski, appellant, against OneBeacon Insurance Company, appellee, in the Circuit Court for Frederick County. Appellant opposes appellee’s assertion that appellee was entitled to a full reimbursement of the monies it paid to appellant

*136

as workers’ compensation benefits for an injury appellant sustained when she fell during the course of her employment, where the appellant, in a separate tort action against a third party arising out of the same incident that caused her compensable injury, recovered from the third party tort-feasor money damages in excess of the amount of compensation paid to her by the employer/insurer.

The case was argued before the Honorable G. Edward Dwyer, Jr. on April 17, 2002. Appellant argued that appellee had no right to reimbursement and, in the alternative, that appellee’s right to reimbursement was at least limited to the same percentage by which appellant herself was limited as to the recovery of a settlement that was reduced as a result of the bankruptcy of the third party tort-feasor whose conduct was the cause of appellant’s injuries. Appellee argued that the plain meaning of Maryland Code (1991, 1999 Repl.Vol.) § 9-902 of the Labor and Employment Article (hereinafter, § 9-902)

1

entitled it to receive a full reimbursement for the compensation award it paid to appellant from appellant’s recovery from the third party tort-feasor. Judge Dwyer granted judgment in favor of appellee. On May 17, 2002, appellant filed a Notice of Appeal to the Court of Special Appeals. This Court, on December 11, 2002, on our own initiative, granted a writ of certiorari to undertake review of this issue before the intermediate appellate court acted.

Podgurski v. Onebeacon,

372 Md. 132, 812 A.2d 288 (2002).

Appellant presents three questions for our review:

“A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.