Supreme Court of Vermont February 21, 2003, 99-265 (State v. Homeside Lending, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-2003

Dooley, J.

¶ 1. The State of Vermont appeals from a decision of the Chittenden Superior Court granting summary judgment to defendants, Homeside Lending, Inc. and BankBoston Corporation, on the grounds that this litigation is precluded by a national class action judgment by the Mobile, Alabama circuit court in

Hoffman v. BancBoston Mortgage Corp.,

No. CV-91-1880 (Ala. Cir. Ct. Jan. 24, 1994). In this action, the State alleges that defendants violated the Vermont Consumer Fraud Act, Vermont’s mortgage escrow account statute, and its fiduciary duties and contractual obligations in implementing the Alabama judgment with respect to Vermont mortgagors who were class members because of their mortgages with defendants. The State argues on appeal that the superior court’s preclusion decision was erroneous because (1) the Alabama circuit court’s assertion of personal jurisdiction over Vermont class members was defective because it violated their due process rights, and (2) even if Vermont mortgagors are precluded by the Alabama judgment from raising the claims asserted in this case, the State is not precluded. We agree with the first argument, do not reach the second, and reverse.

¶ 2. The events underlying

Hoffman

and this lawsuit are notorious, having been the subject of extensive news and academic commentary. See M. Shadur,

The Unclassy Class Action,

23 No. 2 Litig. 3 (Winter 1997); S. Koniak

&

G. Cohen,

Under Cloak of Settlement,

82 Va. L. Rev. 1051, 1068 (1996); B. Meier,

Math of a Class-Action Suit: Winning’ $2.19 Costs $91.83,

N.Y. Times, Nov. 21, 1995, at Al; J. Quinn,

Fighting the System, Everywhere,

Newsweek, Oct. 2, 1995, at 71. The controversy arises out of real estate loans that Bank of Boston Corporation made to Vermont homeowners, as well as to those from other states, that were serviced by BancBoston Mortgage Corporation. The names of these corporations have changed respectively to BankBoston Corporation and Homeside Lending, Inc., the defendants in this case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.