Supreme Court of New Jersey July 10, 2003 (New Jersey Transit Corp. v. Cat in Hat, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-2003

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

LONG, J.

In these consolidated condemnation cases, we are called on to determine whether a trial court may enter an order in an eminent domain proceeding that preserves a governmental condemnor’s ability to bring a separate cost-recovery action against a condemnee for cleanup of contamination and if so, whether that order also may bar the condemnee from later raising the preclusionary defenses of

res judicata,

collateral estoppel and the entire controversy doctrine. In light of our decision today in

Housing Auth. of City of New Brunswick v. Suydam Invs.,

177

N.J. 2,

826 A.2d 673,

*32

2003

WL

21543547 (2003), holding that contamination should not be considered as a valuation issue in a condemnation case, but should be reserved for a separate cost-recovery action, it follows that the reservation of rights clause is legitimate and that res

judicata,

collateral estoppel and entire controversy defenses are unavailable in the later cost-recovery action.

I

A.

Goldman

and

Cat in the Hat

In April 2000, plaintiff New Jersey Transit Corporation (NJT) began condemnation actions against defendant Goldman, Popkin, Caputi, Hegedus and Carom Partnership (Goldman), t/a Best Spot Parking and defendant Cat in the Hat, LLC (Cat in the Hat), T/A Penn Central Parking (collectively condemnees). The subject properties, separately owned, are adjacent commercial parking lots near the Trenton Train Station. The Goldman properties consist of approximately 8,800 square feet, and the Cat in the Hat properties consist of approximately 16,000 square feet. NJT sought to acquire the sites in connection with the construction of its Southern New Jersey Light Rail Transit System between Trenton and Camden. The construction plans for the subject properties call for NJT to construct a station stop terminus, which includes construction platforms, covering canopy, associated lighting, automated ticket vending and various artistic treatments.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.