Supreme Court of Arkansas November 13, 2003, 03-327 (Pederson v. Stracener)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-2003

Jim Hannah, Justice.

William Carl Pederson appeals a decision of the Lonoke County Circuit Court enjoining him from being sworn to his elected position of Justice of the Peace, District 4. Lonoke County residents Carl Stracener and Champion Harvey filed a post-election petition for a writ of mandamus and complaint for declaratory judgment seeking to block Pederson from assuming his elected position. Stracener and Harvey alleged that Pederson was ineligible to stand for election to the position of Justice of the Peace District 4, under amendment 29, section 2, to the Arkansas Constitution, because as a person appointed to fill a vacancy as Justice of the Peace, District 4, he was prohibited from running for the same position in the following election. The trial court agreed and enjoined Pederson from being sworn in as Justice of the Peace, District 4.

Pederson alleges that the trial court erred in considering Stracener’s and Harvey’s action because a petition for a writ of mandamus and complaint for declaratory relief may only be used to make a pre-election challenge to a candidate’s eligibility. Pederson also argues that Stracener and Harvey lack standing to bring the action because while they are residents of Lonoke County, they are not residents of District 4. Finally, Pederson alleges that Stracener and Harvey waived their action by not bringing it pre-election, and that the trial court erred in failing to determine that District 4 had been so altered by reapportionment that he was not succeeding himself to the same position.

Because election contests are purely statutory, and the statutes do not provide for a post-election petition for a writ of mandamus and complaint for declaratory judgment to challenge a candidate’s eligibility, the trial court was without jurisdiction to hear the matter. Because this case is decided on jurisdiction, there is no need to consider the remaining issues. This case is reversed and dismissed.

This court has jurisdiction under Ark.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.