Court of Appeals for the First Circuit May 15, 2003, 02-1810 (Blake v. First Physicians Cor)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2003

United States Court of Appeals

For the First Circuit

No. 02-1810

WILLIAM J. BLAKE, ET AL.,

Plaintiffs, Appellants,

v.

MICHAEL PELLEGRINO, ET AL.,

Defendants, Appellees.

APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS

[Hon. William G. Young, U.S. District Judge]

Before

Selya, Circuit Judge,

Stahl, Senior Circuit Judge,

and Lipez, Circuit Judge.

Philip N. Beauregard, with whom John A. Markey, Jr. and

Beauregard, Burke & Franco were on brief, for appellants.

Curtis Diedrich, with whom Alan B. Rindler, Nadine Nasser

Donovan, Rindler•Morgan, P.C., William J. Davenport, Richard M.

Haley, Bloom & Buell, Stacey Morris, and Sloane & Walsh, LLP were

on consolidated brief, for individual appellees.

J. Peter Kelley, with whom Martin C. Foster and Foster &

Eldridge were on brief, for appellee Southcoast Health Systems,

Inc., d/b/a Charlton Memorial Hospital.

May 15, 2003

SELYA, Circuit Judge. This appeal requires us to explore

the limits of a trial judge's authority to remove a significant

piece of evidence from a jury's consideration based upon his belief

that the evidence lacks persuasive force.1 We conclude that, in

the circumstances of this case, the judge's actions invaded the

province of the jury. Because there is a reasonable likelihood

that the error influenced the eventual verdict, we vacate the

judgment as to the affected claims and remand the case for a new

trial.

I. BACKGROUND

On October 30, 1998, Betty Ann Blake, a profoundly

disabled woman in her mid-forties, was eating her mid-day meal at

a daycare facility. A piece of meat lodged in her throat. She was

taken to the emergency room at Charlton Memorial Hospital (the

Hospital) in Fall River, Massachusetts. Although laypersons

speculated that Betty Ann might be choking, she apparently refused

to open her mouth and the doctors on duty did not conduct a full

examination.

Betty Ann was admitted to the Hospital. The following

day, she had a seizure and began to display labored breathing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.