District Court, N.D. Alabama December 30, 2003, CIV.A. 02-AR-1765-S (Estate of McDonald v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-12-2003
MEMORANDUM OPINION
ACKER, District Judge.
Before the court are cross motions for summary judgment. The first is by defendant, United States of America (“Government”). The second is by plaintiff, the Estate of Peggy Spain McDonald, deceased, (“Estate”). The Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) audited the Estate and determined that $504,723.08 in additional tax was owed. The IRS contends that Alabama law precluded certain actions taken before and after the testatrix’s death and that the Estate had incorrectly calculated its charitable deduction. The Estate paid the amount of the alleged additional tax, plus interest, and, after further proceedings in the state probate court, seeks in this court a refund in the amount of $364,115.13, plus interest.
1
This court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1).
Summary Judgment Facts
Peggy Spain McDonald (“Peggy”) died on April 28, 1996. Her will, executed on August 21,1986, devised personal property to certain individuals and established a family trust for the benefit of her grandchildren and their descendants with 7/8 of the residue estate. Her beneficiaries were unaware of the specifics of the will until after her death.
In a codicil dated October 23, 1987, Peggy directed the trustee to divide the grandchildrens’ family trust in two. A $1 million generation-skipping transfer (“GST”) exemption was allocated to one trust. The other trust would be subject to the GST tax. A second codicil, dated December 9, 1988, added the following provisions to “Item II” of the will:
(f) I hereby forgive any debt owed to me by any child of mine and direct that such debt need not be paid to my estate.
(g) I give and bequeath all shares of the stock of Tour Golf, Inc., owned by me at the time of my death, to my son, William McDonald, to be his absolutely.
A third codicil, dated April 17, 1991, and a fourth codicil, dated May 22, 1991, further revised Item II, but repeated provisions (f) and (g) without change.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit