Supreme Court of Rhode Island November 25, 2003, 2002-165-C.A. (State v. Dumas)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-11-2003
OPINION
FLANDERS, Justice.
Retried and found guilty once again of second-degree murder for strangling a Woonsocket woman, the defendant, Mark Dumas (Dumas or defendant), asks us on appeal to reverse his conviction and to remand this case for a third trial. Insisting that he reasonably believed the victim already was dead when he admittedly tied a rope around her neck and, as the jury found, strangled her, he argues that the trial justice grievously erred by failing to provide the jury with the mistake-of-fact instruction that he requested the court to give. He also posits that the trial justice committed reversible error when he refused to include his lawyer’s cross-examination of a police officer as part of the testimony that the trial justice read back to the jurors when they asked him for “a police witness statement * * * during the time the tape was over and the defendant said, T did it.’ ”
On Dumas’s first appeal,
State v. Dumas,
750 A.2d 420, 426 (R.I.2000)
(Dumas I),
we remanded the case to the Superior Court for it to determine whether Dumas unequivocally had requested a lawyer when the police were questioning him and tape-recording his custodial statements. On remand, the Superior Court ruled that Dumas had done so. Consequently, the court vacated his conviction, granted him a new trial, and suppressed certain statements that the police had obtained from Dumas after he requested to speak with a lawyer. Nevertheless, after the retrial, even after the trial justice excluded the previously contested recording, a second jury also found him guilty of second-degree murder.
Because the facts pertaining to the murder are described fully in
Dumas I,
we will not recapitulate them here. Rather, we shall proceed directly to the two arguments that Dumas raises on his appeal from his murder conviction after the second trial — and to the reasons why we conclude they are unavailing.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit